> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://the-capital-memo.ghost.io/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The Price the World Once Paid a Cent a Pound to Defend
- URL: https://the-capital-memo.ghost.io/the-price-the-world-once-paid-a-cent-a-pound-to-defend/
- Published: 2026-10-24T10:50:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-24T10:49:59.000Z
- Author: James Coleman

Cocoa traded near 5,580 dollars a tonne in New York this week, down about twelve percent on the year. In December 2024 it reached roughly 12,900 dollars, the highest price ever recorded for the commodity. Measured against that peak this is a collapse, and it is reported as one.  
  
Measured against anything else it is not. Cocoa averaged 3,182 dollars in 2023 and spent most of the four decades before that in a band around 2,500\. The price today is still something like seventy five percent above the level the trade considered normal for a generation. What has happened is not a return to earth.  
  
The producers are not seeing it that way, because the farmgate price is not a market price. Côte d'Ivoire set its main crop price for this season at 1,200 CFA francs a kilogram, about 2.07 dollars, down fifty seven percent from 2,800 the season before. Ghana went the other way, raising its producer price to roughly 3.65 dollars a kilogram under a new law guaranteeing farmers at least seventy percent of the realised export price. Two neighbouring countries growing the same crop now pay farmers prices that differ by about three quarters, and Ivorian farmers have been on strike since the middle of September.

### The Historical Echo

There was a time when the international community thought a price like today's was a catastrophe to be prevented, and built an institution to prevent it.  
  
The International Cocoa Agreement was concluded in Geneva on the nineteenth of November 1980 and came into force the following August. Its economic clauses set a price range in cents per pound: a floor of 100, intervention points at 110 and 150, and a ceiling of 160\. A floor of 100 cents a pound is about 2,205 dollars a tonne. The record set in December 2024 was roughly six times the price the agreement existed to hold the market above.  
  
The mechanism was a buffer stock of 250,000 tonnes, funded by a levy of one United States cent on every pound of cocoa crossing a member's border. The manager bought when prices threatened the floor and was meant to sell when they threatened the ceiling.  
  
It bought. It held 100,000 tonnes through the 1985 and 1986 season, 175,000 the following year, and hit its 250,000 tonne ceiling in 1987 and 1988\. Then it stopped, because it had run out of capacity and money, and the price kept falling anyway. The economic clauses lapsed in 1993 and the successor agreement explicitly abandoned the idea of influencing price. The stock, by then 230,000 tonnes, was sold off in monthly instalments over about four and a half years.  
  
It was always going to fail. The United States, the largest consumer, never joined. Côte d'Ivoire, the largest producer, was outside the agreement for part of its life. An arrangement that binds only some of the sellers and none of the buyers is not a cartel. It is a subsidy to everyone outside it.

### Where Patient Capital Is Positioning

The part of this market that deserves attention is not the price but the machinery that reports it.  
  
The International Cocoa Organization, which publishes the production and grinding figures the trade runs on, has temporarily withheld its estimates for the current season and published no forecast for the next. Anyone quoting a surplus or a deficit for 2025 or 2026 is quoting a private model. Liquidity has not come back either: open interest in New York fell from about 403,000 contracts in the spring of 2023 to roughly 154,000 a year later, which means the all time record was set in the thinnest market in a decade.  
  
The demand side is quietly separating from the grind. Third quarter grindings rose twenty nine percent in Asia while the largest listed chocolate manufacturer reported volumes down almost three percent over nine months and retail measurement showed chocolate confectionery volumes down more than five. Processors are rebuilding inventory. Consumers are buying less.  
  
For capital that thinks across generations the lesson of the buffer stock is narrow and durable. A physical commodity whose supply comes from a handful of countries with ageing trees and a disease problem will be volatile, and no institution has ever successfully set its price. What can be owned is the ground, the trees and the processing capacity. What cannot be owned is the number on the screen, and the people who tried to buy it ended up selling 230,000 tonnes into a market that no longer needed them.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/44/88/44885750-7681-4d57-825f-5d69f4c60045/content/images/2026/10/the-price-we-once-paid-a-cent-a-pound-to-defend-editorial.jpg)

The Capital Memo